The Day I Realized Our Onboarding Sucked—Thanks to One Reddit Thread

I’m a product manager at a startup building developer tools, and I thought our onboarding process was pretty solid. We had a shiny README in our GitHub repo, a quickstart guide on our website, and even a few video tutorials. New users could figure it out, right? Wrong. It took a single Reddit thread to make me realize our onboarding was a mess—and it changed how we approached everything.

It was a random Tuesday night, and I was doomscrolling through Reddit’s r/webdev subreddit when I stumbled across a post titled, “What’s the most frustrating dev tool you’ve tried recently?” My curiosity got the better of me, and I clicked. Halfway down the thread, someone mentioned our tool—a SaaS platform for simplifying API documentation. The comment wasn’t kind. “Tried Doc-E.ai last week, and I gave up after 20 minutes. No clue where to start. Docs assume you’re already an expert.”

My stomach dropped. I kept reading, hoping it was a one-off. It wasn’t. Another user chimed in: “Yeah, their setup guide is like a puzzle with missing pieces.” A third added, “I asked for help in their Discord, and it was just chaos—no pinned guides, just endless threads.” The thread had 47 upvotes and counting. I felt like I’d been punched in the gut.

The next morning, I called an emergency meeting with my team. I shared the Reddit thread, and we dug into the feedback. At first, some of us were defensive—“They didn’t read the docs properly!”—but deep down, I knew the truth. Our onboarding wasn’t user-friendly. We’d been so focused on building features that we’d neglected the first impression new users got. It was our fault, not theirs.

That’s when we turned to Doc-E.ai itself—ironic, right? Our own tool, designed to analyze unstructured data from platforms like GitHub, Discord, and Reddit, became our lifeline. We fed it the Reddit thread, our GitHub issues, and a month’s worth of Discord chats from our #help channel. The goal? Find out exactly where users were getting stuck.

Within hours, Doc-E.ai spit out a report that was equal parts humbling and illuminating. Here’s what we learned:

  • Confusing Documentation: Users repeatedly mentioned that our API documentation skipped crucial steps, like environment setup. Comments like “Where do I even put the auth key?” showed up in GitHub issues and Discord chats. We’d assumed too much prior knowledge.
  • Scattered Resources: Our quickstart guide was buried on the website, and the README in our GitHub repo didn’t link to it. Discord users complained about digging through unpinned messages to find answers. No wonder they felt lost.
  • Technical Jargon Overload: Doc-E.ai’s sentiment analysis flagged negative tones in phrases like “What does this error even mean?” Our docs were written for senior devs, alienating beginners.
  • No Clear Path: The Reddit thread highlighted that users didn’t know what to do after signing up. There was no “next step” prompt, leaving them to guess.

Armed with these insights, we got to work. We revamped our onboarding flow, starting with a new welcome email that linked directly to a streamlined quickstart guide. We rewrote our API docs to include step-by-step examples, complete with screenshots. On Discord, we created a pinned FAQ and a dedicated #onboarding channel. We even added an interactive tutorial in the app, walking users through their first API call.

The best part? We used Doc-E.ai to keep tabs on the changes. It monitored new GitHub issues and Discord messages, checking for shifts in sentiment. Within a month, complaints dropped by 60%, and positive comments like “Finally, docs that make sense!” started popping up. Our NPS score climbed 15 points. That Reddit thread, as painful as it was, became our wake-up call.

Looking back, I’m grateful for those brutally honest Redditors. They showed me what I’d been too close to see: good intentions don’t equal good onboarding. Tools like Doc-E.ai helped us turn frustration into progress, proving that listening to users—really listening—can make all the difference. Now, I check Reddit weekly. You never know what you’ll learn.

More blogs

Made in Webflow